City cars Smart Forfour CarsThat Last
EN
Reliability guide

Is the Smart Forfour reliable?

5.3/10
Average
About average for a city car
Likely between 3.9 and 6.6 · 26,691 inspections in 2 countries · updated 13 November 2026

By country. The score combines the countries below, each compared with its own average car.

Netherlands6.2APK inspections · 4,320 cars
United Kingdom4.7MOT tests · 22,371 cars
Norwaynot yetEU-kontroll · Planned

The short answer

Inspectors find technical faults on the Smart Forfour 12% more often than on the average car of the same age and fuel. That makes it number 31 of the 53 city cars we rank.

The countries disagree: it scores 6.2 in the Netherlands and 4.7 in the UK, which is why the likely range is wide.

Not every year is equal. The strongest are 2005, 2006 and 2018. Cars from 2015 and 2016 come out weakest, so check those more carefully.

By fuel type

Hybrids are compared with petrol cars of the same age. Diesel, electric and LPG cars are each compared with their own kind.

Petrol25,928 cars · likely 4.0 to 6.6Netherlands 6.2 · United Kingdom 4.65.3
Electric529 cars · likely 2.3 to 8.2Netherlands 3.8 · United Kingdom 6.25.4

Year by year

Score by year of first registration, newest first. Swipe for more. Years with few cars are only in the list.

20195.11,880 cars
20185.14,305 cars
20174.85,237 cars
Check20163.65,690 cars
Check20154.85,881 cars
Best20066.61,350 cars
Best20056.81,174 cars
20046.4509 cars

What to check

Faults inspectors found clearly more often on the Smart Forfour than on other cars of the same age and fuel.

Exhaust emissions: lambda reading out of range5× usual

Found on 3.0% of cars (petrol) in UK MOT tests, against 0.6% on comparable cars.

Suspension arm ball joint: excessively worn4× usual

Found on 3.1% of cars (petrol) in UK MOT tests, against 0.9% on comparable cars.

Airbag / seatbelt warning light on2× usual

Found on 4.0% of cars (petrol) in Dutch inspections, against 1.9% on comparable cars.

Track rod end excessive play3× usual

Found on 2.3% of cars (petrol) in Dutch inspections, against 0.7% on comparable cars.

Ball joint excessive play2× usual

Found on 2.2% of cars (petrol) in Dutch inspections, against 1.0% on comparable cars.

Exhaust: major leak3× usual

Found on 1.6% of cars (petrol) in UK MOT tests, against 0.5% on comparable cars.

Indicator colour wrong3× usual

Found on 3.9% of cars (petrol) in Dutch inspections, against 1.5% on comparable cars.Not scored

Number plate light not working+45%

Found on 6.8% of cars (petrol) in Dutch inspections, against 4.7% on comparable cars.Not scored

Area by area

Share of cars with a defect in each area at their last inspection.

Smart ForfourAverage car of the same age and fuel
Brakes7.1
17% fewer faults than average · 4.5% against 5.4%
Suspension and steering4.8
22% more faults than average · 9.0% against 7.4%
Engine, drivetrain and leaks9.2
55% fewer faults than average · 1.7% against 3.8%
Exhaust and emissions3.1
62% more faults than average · 4.1% against 2.5%
Rust and structure9.9
81% fewer faults than average · 0.1% against 0.3%
Warning lights, airbags and belts4.5
27% more faults than average · 2.3% against 1.8%

Buying new?

Our data covers cars from about three years old, so it cannot score a car bought new. What it can show is the track record. Smart as a brand scores 6.1 across 97,508 cars. Cars of this model registered from 2019 on score between 5.1 and 5.1 so far.

How we score

What the score measures

Cars in the Netherlands and the UK must pass a periodic roadworthiness inspection: the APK and the MOT. We take each car's most recent inspection and count technical defects: brakes, suspension and steering, engine and leaks, exhaust, rust, and warning lights. Tyres, bulbs and wipers are left out, because they say more about the owner than the car.

Each model is compared with the average car of the same age and fuel in its own country, and in the UK also the same mileage. Then the countries are combined. A score of 6.0 is an average car. A car with half the usual defects scores about 8.9.

What it cannot tell you

Inspections catch wear and corrosion, not most engine, gearbox or electronics failures. Faults repaired before the inspection are never recorded. The Dutch data has no mileage, so we apply the mileage pattern seen in the UK. When the countries disagree about a model, its likely range gets wider and the verdict more careful.

Read the full method About Privacy
Data: RDW open data (CC0) and DVSA MOT data, which contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. Updated 13 November 2026. Cars That Last is independent.